Bookasaurus
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Review Index
  • My Queue

We Were Liars | E. Lockhart

6/13/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
The film release of The Fault in Our Stars last week created a rather heated discussion about the reader base for young adult literature. Ruth Graham wrote an article for Slate lambasting the large percentage of adults who were reading fiction written for teenagers. This incited a wave of responses in magazines and newspapers across the country. To be honest, I see the merits of both sides of the argument. Yes, this is literature aimed at a much younger audience and often I am embarrassed to be reading it. I do agree that often there is more to be learned from books that are more literary and more age appropriate. However, I also know that often when readers pick up a books often they are looking to be entertained.

What honestly surprised me most was learning about the reader base for this genre; I would never have guessed that only 20% of the readers of young adult fiction is the age group targeted (13-17). Many more (27%) were in the 30 – 44 group, and even more still were in the 18-29 category (34%). So, should 80% of those consuming these novels be embarrassed? Should we be reading the literary greats instead or should we just be happy that people are still reading books at all? 

Picture
The entire debate came just as I was finishing up E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars, which was published last month.  I had actually been deciding whether or not to purchase Emma Straub’s The Vacationers, when I saw a reference recommending Lockhart’s novel. My purchase was an impulse buy, and to be honest, I wish I had done a little more research.

It’s hard to say much about the novel without giving away the plot, but the story centers around a 15 year old girl named Cadence and her summers with her family on their private island in Massachusetts. Cadence, alongside her two cousins Johnny and Mirren and their family friend Gat, make up an inseparable group that call themselves “The Liars.” Summer 15 marks a turning point. Once night Cadence is found washed up on shore, naked, hypothermic, with her memory compromised. Over the next year, she struggles to remember what happened. She turns to The Liars, her two cousins and Gat, her first love, to try to uncover a past that her family seems intent on burying.

The premise sounded find to me, but I think my biggest issue was how gimmicky the book felt. Cadence belongs to a wealthy New England family that quarrels over money and has children named things like Mirren, Liberty, and Taft. They “summer” together on an island. The head of the family is Cadence’s grandfather, who shuns outsiders and punishes perceived imperfections with threats of removal from his will. The book oozes stereotypes to a nauseating degree. But that could potentially have been forgiven had the plot been compelling enough in the end – from my perspective, it wasn’t.

I also didn’t find myself attached to any of the characters throughout the course of the story the way one normally does in good young adult fiction. I think one of the great things about the genre is often how much readers connect with characters like Hazel Grace and Gus from The Fault In Our Stars or Charlie from The Perks of Being a Wallflower. The emotional bond and the identifiable struggles are often where these books garner the bulk of their strength.

But there are books, like Gossip Girl, for example that focus on a subset of society and make it work. What We Were Liars lacks is characters that are believable as human beings outside of the realm of fiction. These were not people who could exist outside the realm of imagination. In the end, I would recommend passing on this one. There are better beach reads out there, and others more worth of spending your money on.

As to the young adult fiction debate, I think that despite the slight sense of shame I experience when I realize I’m a college-educated 25 year old who is reading stories targeted at readers a decade younger, I refuse to shun any genre as a whole. In the end, it’s better to be reading something than nothing at all.

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    About

    Just another blog about books. Based in Chicago.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2015
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013

    Categories

    All
    A Constellation Of Vital Phenomena
    Action
    Africa
    A House In The Sky
    All The Light We Cannot See
    Amanda Lindhout
    Amanda Ripley
    American South
    Anthony Doerr
    Anthony Marra
    Art
    Asperger's
    Astrology
    Australian Writers
    Autism
    Ayelet Waldman
    Barbara Demick
    Benazir Bhutto
    Be Safe I Love You
    Best Of 2013
    Bitcoin
    Books
    Botany
    Brothers
    Bryology
    Burial Rights
    Captain Phillips
    Cara Hoffman
    Cat's Cradle
    Chechnya
    Cheryl Strayed
    Coming Of Age
    Daniel James Brown
    Dark
    David And Goliath
    Donna Tartt
    Doug Dorst
    Easy Read
    Education
    Eleanor Catton
    Elizabeth Gilbert
    Emily Lockhart
    Emma Donoghue
    England
    Ethics
    Fantasy
    First Post
    Five Days At Memorial
    France
    Funny
    Gabrielle Zevin
    Gavin Extence
    George Orwell
    Germany
    Graeme Simsion
    Greg Iles
    Hannah Kent
    Helene Wecker
    Historical
    Hungary
    Iceland
    India
    In The Heart Of The Sea
    Japan
    Jean-Dominique Bauby
    Jeannette Walls
    Jhumpa Lahiri
    J.J. Abrams
    John Green
    Jojo Moyes
    Jonas Jonasson
    Kate Atkinson
    Kate Manning
    Kurt Vonnegut
    Liane Moriarty
    Life After Life
    Lithuania
    Looking For Alaska
    Love And Treasure
    Malala Yousafzai
    Malcolm Gladwell
    Marina Keegan
    Me Before You
    Medicine
    Memoir
    Mormon
    My Notorious Life
    Naoki Higashida
    Natchez Burning
    Nathaniel Philbrick
    New Orleans
    New York City
    New Yorker Festival
    Nickolas Butler
    North Korea
    Nothing To Envy: Ordinary Lives In North Korea
    Pakistan
    Plants
    Politics
    Qais Akbar Omar
    Quick Read
    Radio
    Religion
    Room
    Running The Rift
    Rwandan Genocide
    S.
    San Francisco
    Sheri Fink
    Sheryl Sandberg
    Short Books
    Shotgun Lovesongs
    Siblings
    Silly
    Snow In August
    Somalia
    Southern Gothic
    Strong Women
    Sweden
    The 100 Year Old Man
    The Amazing Adventures Of Kavalier And Clay
    The Atlantic
    The Boys In The Boat
    The Diving Bell And The Butterfly
    The Fault In Our Stars
    The Fort Of Nine Towers
    The Girl You Left Behind
    The Glass Castle
    The Goldfinch
    The Golem And The Jinni
    The Lowland
    The Luminaries
    The Opposite Of Loneliness
    The Reason I Jump
    The Rosie Project
    The Signature Of All Things
    The Smartest Kids In The World
    The Storied Life Of A.J. Fikry
    The Universe Versus Alex Woods
    This Dark Road To Mercy
    Travel
    Under The Banner Of Heaven
    Victorian Era
    War
    We Were Liars
    Wild
    Wiley Cash
    Women
    World War Ii
    World War Ii
    Yale
    Young Adult

Proudly powered by Weebly